Victims of sea monsters
or abducted by aliens?
The ocean bound tale straight out of the X Files
There is no greater mystery connected with the sea than the hauntingly silent Marie Celeste. 
Saad Khan and Ayan Tariq in Year 9 retell this traveller’s tale and explains why it continues to mystify
The Mystery of the Marie Celeste
The Mary Celeste remains one of the 
sea’s most unsettling riddles, a story that 
feels as if it drifts just out of reach no 
matter how many times it’s examined. 
In December 1872, the ship was found 
wandering the Atlantic with her sails 
partly set and her hull perfectly sound, yet 
not a single person remained on board. 
The crew’s belongings were still in their 
cabins, the food stores were untouched, 
and the cargo of industrial alcohol was 
almost entirely intact. The only thing 
missing was the lifeboat and the people 
who should have been guiding the vessel 
across the ocean. It was as if life had 
simply evaporated from the deck.
When sailors from the Dei Gratia boarded 
her, they found no signs of violence, no 
struggle, no storm damage. The last log 
entry was calm and ordinary. Captain 
Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, their 
young daughter Sophia, and the seven 
crewmen had vanished without leaving a 
trace. The ship was seaworthy enough to 
complete the journey she had started, yet 
the people aboard had chosen – or been 
forced – to leave her behind.
Theories have swirled around the Mary 
Celeste for more than a century. Some 
imagine a sudden natural event, like a 
waterspout or a rogue wave, frightening 
the crew into abandoning ship. Others 
picture leaking alcohol fumes causing a 
panic, prompting everyone to temporarily 
evacuate in the lifeboat, only for disaster 
to strike before they could return. There 
are whispers of piracy, though nothing 
was stolen, and suggestions of mutiny, 
though no evidence supports it. More 
scientific minds have proposed a 
seaquake, an underwater tremor that 
might have convinced the crew the ship 
was sinking. And then there are the more 
imaginative explanations – sea monsters, 
ghost ships, and other supernatural ideas 
that say more about our love of mystery 
than the facts themselves.
What keeps the Mary Celeste alive in 
the public imagination is not just the 
disappearance but the eerie normalcy of 
everything left behind. The ship wasn’t 
wrecked or looted; it was simply empty, 
as if frozen in the middle of an ordinary 
day. It invites speculation because it 
leaves so much space for it. The ocean 
is vast, and its stories often end 
without answers, but few are 
as hauntingly incomplete 
as this one. The Mary 
Celeste continues to 
drift through history 
the same way she 
drifted through the 
Atlantic – quiet, 
intact, and carrying 
a silence that no 
theory has ever fully 
broken.
Saad Khan, 
Year 9
The Mary Celeste remains history’s 
ultimate maritime ghost story, a chilling 
puzzle where a ship survived perfectly 
intact while its crew vanished into 
thin air. In December 1872, a passing 
vessel spotted the merchant brigantine 
drifting aimlessly in the Atlantic Ocean. 
Expecting a horrific scene of violence 
or piracy, the boarding crew instead 
stepped into an eerie silence: the 
ship’s cargo was secure, personal 
belongings were left untouched, and 
a six-month supply of food and water 
sat undisturbed. Yet, Captain Benjamin 
Briggs, his wife, his young daughter, 
and the seven crew members were 
gone, along with the single lifeboat. 
The ship’s logbook offered no answers, 
ending abruptly with a completely 
normal entry days earlier. What caused 
an experienced captain to abandon 
a perfectly seaworthy ship? While 
theories at the time blamed everything 
from mutiny to sea monsters, modern 
experts believe a sudden panic forced 
a fatal, premature evacuation into a 
treacherous, unforgiving ocean. 
Leaking alcohol fumes may 
have sparked fears of an 
imminent explosion, or 
a faulty pump might 
have fooled the 
captain into thinking 
the vessel was 
sinking. This will 
forever remain 
a mystery to be 
unsolved. 
Ayan Tariq, 
Year 9
43

View this content as a flipbook by clicking here.